We were all shocked and unimaginably saddened to learn last month that Tom Shinness had passed away on February 17, 2017 after a short battle with cancer. Friends and fans have been publicly grieving and sharing videos and thoughts on Facebook, and the family held a “Celebration of Life” service with memories and music on the 25th. I’m glad that Chuck Thompson was able to represent the Harp Guitar Gathering, performing our traditional finale piece “The Water is Wide” with Phil Keaggy. There are many other highlights – photos, videos and stories – shared in the video as well.
I’ve been processing the news for a couple weeks now, listening to his CDs, watching videos and going through my photo archives. Here are a few memories that I’d like to share about my own moments with Tom. If you are so moved, please add your own memories in the comments section below, knowing that this tribute will remain live (archived) for decades to come.
As you know, I’ve been immersed in the harp guitar in one way or another for a few decades. But the “harp guitar community” really didn’t exist, nor take off until Stephen Bennett held a (what would become the first) Harp Guitar Gathering, in Williamsburg, VA in 2003. The next year I was inspired enough to start Harpguitars.net and then return to HGG2 back in Williamsburg. Stephen was already including me as the resident historian (nerd), and also bouncing ideas off me. He said this guy Tom Shinness was going to be one of the features and so I looked him up – but, back then, couldn’t find anything! Of course with no YouTube, web site, CD listing sites, guys like him could be local legends but fly under the radar. As I was then starting to put together an Internet listing of all active harp guitarists, I was understandably curious! SB would only say “Trust me.”
I don’t remember seeing Tom before he took the stage for his Saturday morning segment.
He plugged in, gave a couple test strums, said hello and then…performed.
I’ve of course been to every Gathering and have had a hand in locating and booking a lot of the finest harp guitarists from across the planet. And no one has come close to Tom’s impact on all of us that weekend. Benoit later observed, “Did you see every harp guitarist in the audience when Shinness played? (he then imitated jaw dropping and hanging open)”
Tom was imposing as hell and seemed larger than life. Looking up at him on the short stage he looked a lot bigger than I later found him to be (my size or shorter, with that almost “elfin” air)
I noticed that most photos show him playing in eyes-closed musical reverie. But some of the videos I recently watched captured that penetrating stare he would give each individual as he connected to his audience with unfiltered soul-baring confidence. That’s what I now recall was my first take away from his set that morning in 2004. Rather quiet offstage, he was a rock star on. My impression after that first hour of Tom was a cross between Jimi Hendrix and Harpo Marx. And no, I don’t mean the curly strawberry hair. I vividly recall later sitting privately with a girlfriend he had brought along and sharing with her my observation that he had this natural magnetism – the same thing said of Harpo, whom children and dogs would instinctively seek out.
His Gibson harp guitar sounded glorious through his pickups and amp, with what he called his “magic reverb” – whatever that may have been. Remember “Echo Song”? A simple piece composed with an echo delay on the quarter note. His “improvised” lines would form colors and phrases that were part effect, part composition. A simple eighth note scale on a key change created a mesmerizing motif as the notes cascaded over themselves in lovely harmonies. You can find this at the end of his Many Waters CD.
Tom had driven up with a bunch of his instruments as well. Several of us were hanging around in a hotel room that night (or the next) and Tom walked in with his mando-cello, which he had created out of a smallish, old Alvarez/Yairi 12-string guitar. He said he wanted Stephen to hear a special tune, and proceeded to launch – in full concert performance mode – into “Mando Tap,” with me sitting on the floor right in front of him. That snare hit he did with a finger on the body edge sounded like a shotgun, and the whole piece was a tour de force in musical tapping/rapping/slapping. The key being musical. This video gives a good repetition of it (click image – and note that finger stretch on heavy double courses!). He later handed it to me to try and it was all but unplayable – high, heavy action that probably only his fingers were capable of pulling sound out of (his Gibson HG wasn’t any easier). “Mando Tap” appears on Tom’s Something Inseparable CD.
Remember my harp mandolin solo extravaganza “The Friends I Finally Met”? That was my homage to the players of Harp Guitar Gathering 2, and certainly half of its inspiration was Tom alone – with that hotel room performance fresh in my mind.
What in the world? We knew he wasn’t going to travel to John Doan’s Salem, Oregon Gathering with his Gibson and didn’t expect to see him that year. But he surprised us with something he whipped up just for the event. A cheap double-neck electric guitar with the top neck converted to sub-basses, and then a small bolted-on fretless zither for super-trebles. He succeeded in out-Doaning Doan! With this creation he was thus in a more improvisational mode throughout the weekend.
At HGG5 we were back again in Williamsburg with Stephen hosting and again featured Tom. By this time (2007), Stephen Bennett, John Doan and I had co-produced the groundbreaking harp guitar compilation Beyond Six Strings. We voted to open the CD with Tom’s Translucent Harp CD tune “Don’t Give into Sorrow about Tomorrow,” which was then, and remains, one of the coolest HG tunes ever.
In 2006, I re-licensed the BSS compilation from the gang to start record label and web store Harp Guitar Music. It’s still collecting royalties into the foreseeable future, and Tom’s opening track remains the biggest seller (outside of Andy McKee’s track, post-YouTube phenom). This and funds from the last of his consignment CDs he left with me will be routed to his daughters from here on.
In 2008, I released the second HGM compilation Harp Guitar Dreams, this time with the majority of tunes being written by the artists specifically for this “concept album.” However, communicating my intended concept to the participants proved trickier than I thought (“Think New Age,’ but not lame” being one of my more articulate instructions…Stephen Bennett actually had to bow out because as he explained, his music “literally reeks of melody.”). Tom gamely sent in a series of quick themes and, while it was of course a thrill to be privy to his private creative process and demo recordings, he wasn’t quite getting it either. Mentioning that a tune like “Dulcitar” (from his Translucent Harp CD, which he referred to as “my Sgt Peppers”) was perfect for what I was envisioning, he mentioned that he had in fact played around with that on harp guitar from time to time (it was originally an ensemble piece centered around the dulcitar). And so, “Dulcitar Dreams” was born, our first professional collaboration! Tom was thrilled to share his music, and also a fan of others’. Of my Dreams piece on the Knutsen “zither-harp-guitar,” he said “I am absolutely blown away by your piece. Those are the kind of sounds I want to make. I used to perform surrounded by 2-3 zithers on a keyboard stand, and play them and the guitar at the same time. Sometimes I would gaffer-tape zithers to the tops of my guitars and acoustic bass guitar. I wish I would have persisted with it. It was a lot of maintenance at gigs!” I was similarly blown away by his praise, but also in envisioning his creative efforts to produce it live on stage.
2010 saw Tom back at the Harp Guitar Gathering 8 in Indiana, hosted by Brad Hoyt. Above, he performs his incredible rendition of Hendrix’ “Little Wing”.
Meanwhile, I was thick in the midst of preparing the Christmas Present HGM release for the following November. Here’s how Tom’s participation on that transpired:
During one of the Gatherings, Tom came up to me, lamenting that he wasn’t on Christmas Past, the other compilation I opened my label with. It included highlights from all the previous harp guitar holiday albums released up to that point (pre-2006). Five of us had done releases that included harp guitar, and I wanted to document and open with that “archival material.” I had inadvertently left off Tom, as I had no way of knowing he had done a self-made Christmas tape/CD many years before. I certainly would have included his beautiful rendition of “Silent Night” on harp guitar, accompanying his friend, session violinist Stephen Dudash. And so now I asked for a newly recorded version of it for Present. He went all out, completely rearranging it, with all manner of stylistic touches and modulations. At my request, he hired Stephen again, who was only too happy to improve upon it himself. So much so that their demo had Tom too much in the background for a “harp guitar album,” and so I implored them to try again with their musical roles more equal. That’s when he came up with an almost completely new third arrangement (as did Stephen with his incredible violin part) – and that’s what you hear on the CD. Or would be. I was paying for the track and so Tom and I agreed I should take on mixing it (from scratch from dry tracks…imagine having to be the one to put reverb on Shinness’ Gibson!). In fact, we went back and forth a bit on reverb levels as I threaded the needle. In the end, I received this nice commendation: “You did a great job mixing my song! Normally I’d have to have my hands all over it, but I knew I could trust you. It’s rare these days to find people who are detailed oriented as you. Thanks for everything that you’ve done for me and the harp guitar community!”
But that was only one track of four duets on this album of all-new harp guitar material. I had this really strange arrangement from a 2000-ish unfinished project of “My Favorite Things” from Sound of Music. Being lazy and knowing that a lot of artists have thrown it on their Holiday albums solely on the basis of a few “wintery” lyrics, I chose to submit this one (yes, to myself, but also assistant Frank Doucette). My old demo arrangement consisted of my Dyer harp guitar with a sampled upright bass – both plucked and arco – playing melody and counterpoint bass notes to the Dyer’s sub-bass notes. I was planning on booking a pro L.A. studio bassist for the recording when I remembered, Hey! Tom was a professional bassist – and a harp guitarist, friend, and on the album himself. Yes, it was a Homer Simpson D’oh! moment just in time.
Quick Sidebar: Speaking of which, remember when I turned a bunch of us into Simpsons characters for my HGG5 Anniversary presentation? People said afterwards that Tom was in the back of the audience seats just killing himself. No one had ever seen him in such hysterics. I love that story, and just wish I would’ve spotted him during.
Back to my tune – so I sent Tom the demo and score, he again raved about the arrangement, then shortly sent me a rough cut and a final. Bravo! His tight playing helped make my challenging “bass on bass” arrangement work. I’m sure anyone who has had the pleasure of having Tom play in their show or on their record feels as honored as I was. Keyboardist/harp guitarist Brad Hoyt was another Shinness fan and asked Tom to play cello on his second harp guitar album Far Away From Everyday.
At the 10th Harp Guitar Gathering in Texas – sadly the last Gathering Tom made it to – he drove down with his Gibson and cello and made his presence felt throughout the weekend – on stage for his final solo set for us, and improvising with Hiro and others on cello. In these moments it seemed as if he had been playing with these impromptu partners all his life, as they were so in tune with each other. It didn’t matter if it was a Beatles tune he knew backwards and forwards or something Hiro just sprung on him. He was instantaneously and constantly only in the pure musical moment.
I think we were all thrilled for Tom when he got his touring gig with Keb’ Mo’ in 2014. Not only did he make some good money, good music and national exposure, but he got to bring his harp guitar! He shared some of that story with us in my blog Harp Guitar Blues.
Unbelievably, he was right down the street from me (15 minutes down the freeway staying at the Sportsman Lodge) when Keb’ and Co. did the Tonight Show or one of those. I invited him and the whole gang over, but Tom couldn’t break away. They later played a couple hours away, and I couldn’t make the show. He so wanted to come visit but we couldn’t make it happen that trip. Alas, this was to my everlasting regret. Can you imagine Tom Shinness in the Miner Museum?! He would’ve never been able to leave, he probably would have simply moved in…and I don’t think I would have let him out without first recording an album with a hundred or so different instruments.
“You somehow play each note as if it were the most important note in the world…” This – or something like it – is what I said to him after experiencing him at HGG2. I’ve never thought that about any of my guitar heroes, before or since. And clearly I wasn’t the first or only fan to come up with this exact observation (he later alluded to this in our last private conversation – apparently a lot of fans shared these exact same and similar words to him throughout his career). No matter where or for whom, when he played anything, he played with all his heart and pure love of the music and sharing it with an audience. He may have played it a thousand (and probably more) times, but it seemed as if one was witnessing a tune’s first and last performance; this was it, this was the performance.
Thank you, Tom, for performing for us.